The AI music landscape is evolving faster than ever. At Busy Works Beats, we are always on the lookout for the next tool that will change the game for producers. Today, a new open-source contender has entered the chat: HeartMuLa.
In this post, we’re breaking down how this open-source model stacks up against the current king of AI music, Suno AI.
What is HeartMuLa?
HeartMuLa is a family of open-source music foundation models designed to handle everything from music understanding to full-track generation. Unlike proprietary models, being open-source means the community can build upon it. The framework includes:
-
HeartCLAP: For audio-text alignment.
-
HeartCodec: A high-fidelity music tokenizer.
-
HeartTranscriptor: A lyric recognition model.
-
HeartMuLa: The core engine that generates the music.
The Head-to-Head Tests
We took the same prompts and lyrics and ran them through Suno (V4.5 and V5) and HeartMuLa. Here is what we found:
1. Cafe Pop (Warm & Reflective)
-
The Vibe: Suno V4.5 showed great stereo imaging, but the vocals had that typical AI "high-frequency noise."
-
HeartMuLa’s Edge: Surprisingly, HeartMuLa’s vocals felt less noisy than Suno V4.5 in this test. The guitar performance was clean and felt incredibly real.
-
Suno V5 Response: However, when we brought in the latest Suno V5, it regained the lead with much more natural phrasing and a wider 3D soundstage.
2. R&B (Keyboard & Electric Guitar)
-
The Result: This test revealed the "songwriting" gap. Suno V4.5 created a track that felt like a finished production with rhythmic syncopation.
-
The Weakness: HeartMuLa’s vocals here were "grainy." This is often because open-source models are trained on audio where vocals were separated using stem-splitters, leading to artifacts that Suno has managed to polish out.
3. Energetic EDM (Electronic & Heavy)
-
The Surprise: HeartMuLa actually took the win for instrumental density. The kick and bass felt "heavy" and grounded.
-
Suno’s Struggle: Interestingly, Suno V5 can sometimes sound a bit "thin" or overly compressed in the EDM genre. If you’re looking for weight in your drums, HeartMuLa is showing massive potential.
4. The Sad Ballad (Soft & Immersion)
-
The Winner: Suno AI. The immersion and emotional "breathiness" of the vocals in Suno V5 are currently unmatched.
-
HeartMuLa’s Struggle: The open-source model sounded a bit "hollow" here, with some strange phasing issues in the stereo field.
Final Thoughts: Open-Source vs. Proprietary
Is HeartMuLa better than Suno? Not quite yet. Suno still holds the crown for vocal quality and emotional "vibe." However, HeartMuLa is a massive win for the open-source community, offering incredible instrumental weight and a noise-free top end in certain genres.
The Sleeper Pick: While everyone is watching Suno and HeartMuLa, keep an eye on Google. They are cooking up something in the AI music space that might just reset the standard once again.
Leave a comment